CONTROVERSIA
Portrait of Danielle Smith

Photo: Wikimedia Commons

Born in Canada · Nationality Canadian — Politics / institutions

Danielle Smith

Politics and government

Documented profile covering 11 controversies, including “Refusal to exclude two Wildrose candidates over homophobic and racist remarks during 2012 campaign” and “Suggestion that recalled beef could be cooked and donated to homeless people”.

Are you concerned? Right of reply

Profile No. 0766 · Updated on 12 October 2026

Portrait of Danielle Smith

Photo: Wikimedia Commons
11Documented controversies
20Sources
0Formal charge · all time
0Conviction

§ Legal statuses reflect the documented sources as of the date shown; they replace neither court decisions nor the presumption of innocence. Counts are not a rating. Methodology

I. Documented controversies

01

2025–2026

AHS healthcare contracts scandal: allegations, governance conflicts and Wyant report finding no evidence of wrongful interference by Smith

Investigation

Following the dismissal of former AHS CEO Athana Mentzelopoulos, a lawsuit and subsequent revelations alleged pressure and irregularities in healthcare contracts. The government-commissioned Wyant report identified conflicts of interest and procurement and governance problems that were widely known within the system.

State of the evidence
Allegations

Sources · 2

  1. [1]
    CityNews / The Canadian PressReport into Alberta Health Services contracts finds conflicts widely knownMediaHigh reliability
  2. [2]
    Global News / The Canadian PressReport into Alberta Health Services contracts finds conflicts widely knownMediaHigh reliability

Last verified: 5 September 2026

Add to this entry

02

2024–2025

Laws restricting care, sport and certain school policies for trans young people challenged in court and then protected by notwithstanding clause

Civil / administrative proceedings

The Smith government adopted a package of measures concerning puberty blockers and medical treatments for trans minors, sports participation and school rules on pronouns. The legislation prompted constitutional challenges, and part of the regime was suspended by the courts.

State of the evidence
Documented
Attribution
Directly implicated

Sources · 3

  1. [1]
    CityNews CalgaryAlberta introduces transgender youth legislationMediaHigh reliability
  2. [2]
    CityNews CalgaryCourt challenges to Alberta transgender laws to continueMediaHigh reliability
  3. [3]
    CityNews CalgaryAlberta invokes notwithstanding clause for transgender lawsMediaHigh reliability

Last verified: 5 September 2026

Add to this entry

03

2021–2023

Comparison of Covid-19 vaccine recipients with Hitler's supporters, followed by apology

No legal proceedings

A 2021 interview resurfaced in 2023 in which Smith compared people who had accepted Covid-19 vaccination with populations that had succumbed to the appeal of a tyrant such as Hitler, while explaining that she would not wear a Remembrance Day poppy that year.

State of the evidence
Documented
Legal status — source text
No legal proceedings
Attribution
Personally implicated

Sources · 2

  1. [1]
    Global News / The Canadian PressDanielle Smith apologizes for comments linking COVID vaccinated to Nazi followersMediaHigh reliability
  2. [2]
    Global News / The Canadian PressUCP Leader Danielle Smith declines to speak on previous COVID vaccine, Nazi commentsMediaHigh reliability

Last verified: 5 September 2026

Add to this entry

04

2023

Breach of conflict-of-interest legislation for intervention with Justice Minister in Artur Pawlowski case

No legal proceedings

Alberta's Ethics Commissioner concluded that Smith had breached section 3 of the Conflict of Interest Act by discussing with her Justice Minister a prosecution involving pastor Artur Pawlowski, who had been involved in the Coutts protests. The Commissioner described interference by a Premier in the administration of justice as a threat to democracy.

State of the evidence
Documented
Attribution
Personally implicated

Sources · 2

  1. [1]
    Office of the Ethics Commissioner of AlbertaAllegations involving the Premier of Alberta Danielle Smith — May 17, 2023Official documentVery high reliability
  2. [2]
    CityNews / The Canadian PressTimeline of Alberta Premier Danielle Smith and controversy over COVID court casesMediaHigh reliability

Last verified: 5 September 2026

Add to this entry

05

2023

Alleged interference in hiring and withdrawal of Deena Hinshaw at AHS; Ethics Commissioner finds no wrongdoing

No legal proceedings

Two senior Alberta Health Services officials said they had resigned following withdrawal of a job offer to former Chief Medical Officer of Health Deena Hinshaw, one accusing Smith of intervening directly in the decision. The affair prompted calls for an investigation from doctors.

State of the evidence
Allegations
Attribution
Directly implicated

Sources · 2

  1. [1]
    CityNews Calgary / The Canadian PressNo rules broken in Hinshaw firing: Alberta’s ethics commissionerMediaHigh reliability
  2. [2]
    Global NewsPremier Danielle Smith denies interference in Hinshaw’s hiring at Alberta Health ServicesMediaHigh reliability

Last verified: 5 September 2026

Add to this entry

06

2022-07

Claim that cancer before stage four is 'completely within your control', followed by clarification

No legal proceedings

As a candidate for the UCP leadership, Smith said on a podcast that the factors leading to a cancer diagnosis before stage four were 'completely within your control', prompting criticism from doctors, patients and political rivals over misinformation and blaming patients.

State of the evidence
Documented
Legal status — source text
No legal proceedings
Attribution
Personally implicated

Sources · 2

  1. [1]
    CityNews VancouverUCP leadership candidate Danielle Smith's cancer claimsMediaHigh reliability
  2. [2]
    CityNews CalgarySmith slammed for cancer misinformation in UCP debateMediaHigh reliability

Last verified: 5 September 2026

Add to this entry

07

2022-10

Unvaccinated people described as most discriminated-against group she had seen in her lifetime

No legal proceedings

Shortly after becoming Premier, Smith stated that unvaccinated people were the most discriminated-against group she had ever seen in her lifetime, prompting criticism from organisations representing groups historically subjected to discrimination.

State of the evidence
Documented
Legal status — source text
No legal proceedings
Attribution
Personally implicated

Sources · 2

  1. [1]
    CityNews CalgaryDanielle Smith says unvaccinated are most discriminated groupMediaHigh reliability
  2. [2]
    CityNews EdmontonDanielle Smith clarifies 'most discriminated' commentsMediaHigh reliability

Last verified: 5 September 2026

Add to this entry

08

2022-11/12

Initial Alberta Sovereignty Act granting extraordinary powers to Cabinet, followed by retreat

No legal proceedings

The initial version of the Alberta Sovereignty Within a United Canada Act would have allowed Cabinet to amend certain provincial laws by regulation under sovereignty resolutions. Lawyers, opposition politicians and even allies criticised the excessive executive powers.

State of the evidence
Documented
Attribution
Directly implicated

Sources · 1

  1. [1]
    CityNews / The Canadian PressAlberta government to amend sovereignty bill after criticismMediaHigh reliability

Last verified: 5 September 2026

Add to this entry

09

2014-11/12

Mass defection from Wildrose to Progressive Conservatives after assurances there would be no further defections

No legal proceedings

In late November 2014, after two MPs had left, Smith stated that there would be no more Wildrose defections. Weeks later, she and eight other MPs crossed the floor to join Jim Prentice's Progressive Conservative government, triggering a major crisis of trust among Wildrose voters.

State of the evidence
Documented
Legal status — source text
No legal proceedings
Attribution
Personally implicated

Sources · 2

  1. [1]
    Global NewsWildrose leader says there will be no more floor-crossersMediaHigh reliability
  2. [2]
    CityNews / The Canadian PressRise and fall of Alberta Wildrose party inextricably linked to Danielle SmithMediaHigh reliability

Last verified: 5 September 2026

Add to this entry

10

2012-04

Refusal to exclude two Wildrose candidates over homophobic and racist remarks during 2012 campaign

No legal proceedings

Days before the 2012 election, two Wildrose candidates became embroiled in controversies over homophobic or racist statements. Smith refused to exclude them immediately, invoking freedom of conscience among other considerations, and the episode dominated the end of the campaign.

State of the evidence
Documented
Legal status — source text
No legal proceedings

Sources · 1

  1. [1]
    CityNews / The Canadian PressRise and fall of Alberta Wildrose party inextricably linked to Danielle SmithMediaHigh reliability

Last verified: 5 September 2026

Add to this entry

11

2012-10

Suggestion that recalled beef could be cooked and donated to homeless people

No legal proceedings

During the recall of XL Foods beef linked to E. coli, Smith repeated a suggestion that the meat could be thoroughly cooked and then given to homeless people, provoking a strong reaction from charities and food safety experts.

State of the evidence
Documented
Legal status — source text
No legal proceedings
Attribution
Personally implicated

Sources · 2

  1. [1]
    Global NewsAlberta Wildrose leader Danielle Smith says mistake to tweet meat for homelessMediaHigh reliability
  2. [2]
    Global NewsFood banks say they wouldn't accept recalled beef even with E. coli killed through cookingMediaHigh reliability

Last verified: 5 September 2026

Add to this entry

II. Constellation of documented links

  • Linked profile (portrait or initials) — click to open it
  • Line width: number of documented references
  • Hover over or tap a line: controversies and sources

Two profiles are linked when a documented controversy of one names the other. The link points to that controversy and its sources; it does not indicate a personal relationship.

List of documented links (2)
  1. Mark Carney1 documented reference
  2. Preston Manning1 documented reference

III. Has something changed?

A new court decision, a missing source, a mistake? Tell us what should be updated: every request is read by the editorial team.

Update request

Danielle Smith

Say which controversy is concerned and, if possible, give a source. Between 10 and 2,500 characters.

0 / 2500

To prevent abuse, the approximate location of your connection is recorded with your request.

iPhone and iPad

Install Controversia

  1. Tap Share
  2. then Add to Home Screen

Tap Share, then Add to Home Screen.