Élisabeth Lévy

On CNews, Élisabeth Lévy described immigration as 'the mother of all battles' and stated that many French people feared becoming 'cultural minorities in their own country'. These expressions form part of her longstanding criticism of immigration and multiculturalism and have prompted controversies over the concept of cultural replacement.

State of the evidence

Documented

Attribution

Personally implicated

Élisabeth Lévy had agreed to be interviewed for an episode of 'Complément d'enquête' about CNews before withdrawing her consent shortly before filming. She explained her decision by citing loyalty to the channel and distrust of how the France 2 programme would portray it.

Attribution

Directly implicated

Élisabeth Lévy described the European Convention on Human Rights as an 'absurd treaty' in August 2024, during a debate on immigration, asylum and European states' room for manoeuvre. This position fuelled debate about challenging European standards protecting fundamental rights.

State of the evidence

Documented

Attribution

Personally implicated

Causeur published a cover entitled 'Smile, you are being replaced [Souriez, vous êtes grand-remplacés]' illustrated with non-White babies. The cover sparked fierce controversy, and DILCRAH announced a referral to the public prosecutor, while minister Élisabeth Moreno called it 'abhorrent'.

State of the evidence

Documented

Attribution

Directly implicated

A segment of 'L'Heure des pros' on CNews devoted to climate deteriorated into a highly tense confrontation between Élisabeth Lévy and environmentalist Claire Nouvian. The discussion, which began with remarks about cold weather in May, was criticised for turning a scientific subject into a personal and ideological confrontation.

State of the evidence

Documented

Attribution

Directly implicated

During the national burkini controversy, Élisabeth Lévy presented the garment as a sign of the advance of Islamism and argued that France could legitimately protect a cultural identity and shared customs. Her positions prompted criticism describing them as stigmatising Muslims.

State of the evidence

Documented

Attribution

Personally implicated

In Causeur, Élisabeth Lévy argued that racism as a private thought or opinion should not be confused with offences arising from its public expression, criticising what she considers an excessive extension of legal restrictions on debate.

State of the evidence

Documented

Attribution

Personally implicated

Causeur, edited by Élisabeth Lévy, published the manifesto nicknamed that of the '343 bastards' in 2013, entitled 'Touche pas à ma pute', opposing the criminalisation of prostitution clients. The text and its title provoked a political and feminist outcry, with some denouncing it as further humiliation of women in prostitution.

State of the evidence

Documented

Attribution

Directly implicated