2018–2024
They Shall Not Grow Old: Controversy over Colourisation, Reframing and Ethics of Archive Restoration
The digital transformation of First World War archive footage in They Shall Not Grow Old was praised by audiences but strongly debated among archivists and historians. Criticism concerned colourisation, added frames, reframing, the term "restoration", the obscuring of prior work by Imperial War Museums, and the focus on a white British male experience.
- State of the evidence
- archivists' criticism and academic research documented
- Legal status — source text
- no judicial proceedings
- Attribution
- direct artistic responsibility as director and promoter of the digital transformations
Sources · 3
- [1]BFI / Sight and SoundThey Shall Not Grow Old review: Peter Jackson brings controversial colour to WWI footageMediaHigh reliability
- [2]Studies in European Cinema / Taylor & FrancisThe Battle of the Somme (1916) and They Shall Not Grow Old (2018): archivists, historians, lies and the archiveAcademic publicationHigh reliability
- [3]American Historical Review / Oxford AcademicWho Gets to Be in the War Story? Absences and Silences in They Shall Not Grow OldAcademic publicationHigh reliability
Last verified: 30 August 2026
